Over the past four decades, Green Mountain at Fox Run has helped thousands of women end weight loss struggles with eating, exercise and body image, make long-term healthy lifestyle changes and lose weight permanently. This weight loss blog helps women navigate these changes.

6 Healthy Eating Mistakes That Can Cause You to Overeat

6 Healthy Eating Mistakes That Can Cause You to OvereatAt Green Mountain at Fox Run, sometimes it seems like we’re all about being contrary to popular opinion.

But that’s because popular opinion is so often off track in terms of how to reach and maintain your healthy weight.  So read the following list with that thought in mind.

We think these typical “healthy” eating tips, garnered from the media and elsewhere, can actually be a set-up for overeating. (Actually we’d also argue whether some of them are really healthy.)

1 Only Eat Fresh Foods

Fresh foods are wonderful. The taste is generally, well, fresher, and they may be more nutritious at times. But emphasis on the “at times”. If that fresh food has sat around for a while, its frozen counterpart might be a better choice from a nutrition perspective.

But we’re really not talking about nutrition here. How this notion can lead to overeating has to do with convenience.

If we think we “should” only eat fresh, then when we can’t because of time or energy or lack of access, there’s no in-between. It’s either fresh or fast food. Or fresh or the bag of chips.  Or fresh or…you get the picture.


SOLUTION: Expand your healthy eating repertoire to include frozen and even canned foods

Especially canned beans. They can form the basis for a healthy meal made in minutes.

My fav: Refried beans on tortilla topped with shredded cheese (that I keep in my freezer so it lasts) and sour cream (if it hasn’t molded in the fridge) with onions, lettuce, tomato and salsa. It’s a mix of fresh, canned and frozen! And oh so tasty!!

2Bring Your Own Food To A Party

We’ve all heard this one. It’s often suggested as a way to stop us from eating all the “bad” food at the party. Trouble is, we like that food! And if we go in with the idea that we shouldn’t eat it, then all-or-nothing thinking kicks in when we (inevitably) do.

SOLUTION: Go to the party well-fed.

That means not saving calories at previous meals. Then mindfully eat what you want, enjoying it as you do. That way, you can better discover what you don’t enjoy…and not eat it. If you need a little help, the old advice to not stand next to the chips and dip can help…but that works best if you believe you can have it if you want it.

3If It’s Healthy, It’s Free

You can eat all you want of “healthy” foods, right? So how do you define healthy?

Usually, when used in the context of this idea, it means low calorie. What happens when we overeat (yes, overeat) on low-calorie foods, we can end up feeling stuffed but still not well-fed.

That can distort our idea of how much food it takes for us to feel satisfied if we do it often enough.

SOLUTIONEat well-balanced meals in response to your hunger and appetite cues.

Honor those cues – they’re your best guide for what, when and how much to eat for well-being.

4 Don’t Eat After Dinner

Another one we’ve all heard a lot. So what happens if you’re hungry? Go to bed with your stomach growling? And wake up in the middle of the night and raid the refrigerator?

The only problem with eating late at night is if it interferes with your sleep. It will not cause you to gain weight if you are eating in response to physical hunger.

SOLUTION: Eat enough of well-balanced meals during the day and at dinner, too.

You may still want a snack in the evening but it usually doesn’t need to be a whole meal or more.

5Avoid Conventionally Grown Fruits And Vegetables

We’re all for organic but there are times when it’s just not available. If you skip the veggies because they’re not organic, you may find yourself eating more of richer foods than you might have. Do that often enough and you, well, you know.

SOLUTION: Adopt an in-between stance on organic.

Eat organic as much as is realistic for you. But know that your body is a powerful detoxing machine so unless you’re ill, it can probably detox conventionally-grown produce.

6Avoid Breads, Rice, Etc., At Restaurants If Not Whole Grain

This is like the fruit and veggie point. If you cut these carbohydrate-rich foods in a try for the ultimate in nutrition, you may find yourself hungry and end up eating more of other foods. Very often, those end up being sweets; cutting carbs often leads to sweet cravings.

SOLUTION: Go whole-grain when you can but make your first priority a balanced meal.

I can come up with more but this will get you started. Bottom line: Healthy eating can wear a number of different faces so when you hear specific advice, think whether it really works for you. If it doesn’t, it’s likely not healthy.

Learn About Our Nutrition Program

5 Foods You Should Never Eat: The Green Mountain Version

By on 03/12/2015

We’ve All Seen It… To anyone who has ever surfed the web, this needs no explanation.  We’ve all seen it, the advertisement lingering on the right hand side of your browser, the one with the over ripe helpless little banana illustration that frames the handwritten words “5 Foods You Should Never Eat”. It’s the same one that shows up on […] Read more »

5 Foods You Should Never Eat

The Binge Eating Diaries: What is Normal Eating?

By on 03/11/2015

My Journey to Healthy Eating I’m allergic to peanuts. I can’t stand the texture of mushrooms. I have equal parts salty and sweet teeth. I think raisins and onions are the perfect combination in a salad. I could eat raw cashews for days. I give kale, apples, and cake 5 stars each. For most of my life, my rapport with […] Read more »

My Journey to Healthy Eating

Healthy Recipe: Green Mountain Goddess Dressing

By on 03/10/2015

Here’s Our Rendition of the Old Classic Green Goddess Dressing The biggest difference is that we cut out the buttermilk, simply because it isn’t a typical ingredient that we have kicking around the kitchen so we use yogurt instead. And we put all of the ingredients in the blender at once and blend it rather than slowly adding ingredients separately. […] Read more »

Healthy Recipe Green Goddess Dressing

Is Jogging Really Bad For You?

By on 03/05/2015

Study: Strenuous Joggers As Likely To Die As Sedentary Non-Joggers I have to admit I did an internal victory dance (like the ones football players do when they score a touchdown) after reading about the study posted by the Journal of American College of Cardiology, which reported that jogging is bad for you – well, strenuous jogging for long periods […] Read more »

Strenuous Joggers As Likely To Die As Sedentary Non-Joggers
Ask a Question

Ask Us Anything!